view in publisher's site

Posthumous consecration in rock’s legitimating discourse

Highlights•This article acknowledges the lifetime and posthumous dimensions of cultural consecration.•Death plays a critical role in how cultural fields achieve autonomy.•Field-level dynamics shape how critics frame reputations, both in life and in posterity.•In their album reviews, rock critics value coherence and are more likely to attribute coherence to rockers and their bodies of work in posterity.AbstractThis article advances the concept of posthumous consecration. I first draw on previous literature to demonstrate that posthumous reputations are important components of fields before conceptualizing a “posthumous” variant of cultural consecration and then adopting this concept in thematic and content analyses of rock album reviews. Through my analyses of 336 lifetime and posthumous album reviews, I find two salient discursive processes in the album review sections of rock magazines that follow in the wake of the death of a consecrated figure. First, critics revise the categorical boundaries spanned by rock artists after their deaths. I find striking patterns in how critics draw comparisons between rockers who made their recording debut either before or after 1975 that suggest the categorical membership(s) ascribed by critics to living and dead public figures in a cultural field are dependent on the degree of autonomy at the level of the field. I use this finding to develop the argument that death plays a critical role in how cultural fields achieve autonomy. Second, I find that irrespective of whether the field has a high or low degree of autonomy, critics ascribe coherence to an artist’s body of work to a much greater extent in reviews of posthumous offerings compared to reviews of lifetime offerings. I argue that coherence is highly valued within rock’s legitimating discourse and critics are more likely to attribute coherence to the works of deceased rock musicians which contributes to their symbolic advantage over their living counterparts.

تقدیس consecration در گفتمان legitimating راک

ترجمه شده با


پر ارجاع‌ترین مقالات مرتبط:

  • مقاله Language and Linguistics
  • ترجمه مقاله Language and Linguistics
  • مقاله زبان و زبان‌شناسی
  • ترجمه مقاله زبان و زبان‌شناسی
  • مقاله Communication
  • ترجمه مقاله Communication
  • مقاله ارتباطات
  • ترجمه مقاله ارتباطات
  • مقاله Literature and Literary Theory
  • ترجمه مقاله Literature and Literary Theory
  • مقاله ادبیات و تئوری ادبی
  • ترجمه مقاله ادبیات و تئوری ادبی
  • مقاله Linguistics and Language
  • ترجمه مقاله Linguistics and Language
  • مقاله زبان‌شناسی و زبان
  • ترجمه مقاله زبان‌شناسی و زبان
سفارش ترجمه مقاله و کتاب - شروع کنید

95/12/18 - با استفاده از افزونه دانلود فایرفاکس و کروم٬ چکیده مقالات به صورت خودکار تشخیص داده شده و دکمه دانلود فری‌پیپر در صفحه چکیده نمایش داده می شود.